Release JLex Review v6.6.2

The Future of Joomla in the Age of AI: Build or Buy?

Artificial intelligence is changing how websites are built and maintained. For Joomla users, it offers an appealing possibility: describe a feature, generate the code, and add functionality without starting a traditional development project.

But does easier code generation make Joomla and its extension ecosystem less relevant?

The more likely outcome is a change in how people use them. AI can help create small tools and adapt existing extensions, while Joomla provides a foundation for managing content, users, and website functionality. The important decision is knowing when to build with AI—and when an existing solution offers better value.

Why Joomla Still Matters in an AI-Driven World

Generating code is only one part of running a website. A working site also needs consistent permissions, maintainable features, compatibility, and ongoing updates.

Joomla already provides capabilities such as multilingual content, access control, and publishing workflows. Its product strategy identifies these strengths alongside its extension ecosystem and community ownership as central to its future. Joomla’s product strategy

These foundations remain useful even when AI makes custom development more accessible. A generated feature still needs somewhere reliable to operate, and website owners still need a practical way to manage it.

For Joomla, the opportunity is to make customization easier while retaining the benefits of an established content management system.

AI Can Help You Build Small Joomla Tools

AI is particularly useful for narrowly defined tasks. A tool with one clear purpose is easier to describe, test, and maintain than a large application with many connected features.

Possible examples include:

  • A calculator that runs in the visitor’s browser without storing information.
  • A simple text-formatting utility.
  • A visual enhancement for an existing page.
  • A small interactive widget that uses public, non-sensitive information.

If you lack deep technical expertise, keep the scope modest. Prefer tools that do not require complex database interactions, user authentication, payments, or access to private information.

Even a small tool needs testing. Avoiding database access reduces complexity, but it does not automatically make generated code secure. Check that the tool behaves correctly with unexpected input and does not interfere with the rest of your website.

Larger AI Projects Have Costs Beyond the First Draft

The first generated version can make custom development look inexpensive. The real cost becomes clearer when you start testing and maintaining it.

AI coding tools process tokens—units of text and code—when reading instructions, examining files, and producing responses. Larger projects can consume substantial numbers of tokens across repeated development cycles.

That consumption continues after the initial generation:

  • Debugging: Explaining errors, sharing relevant code, and testing proposed fixes.
  • Refining: Adjusting behavior, improving usability, and handling overlooked situations.
  • Updating: Adapting the tool when Joomla, PHP, dependencies, or business requirements change.
  • Reviewing: Checking compatibility, permissions, and security.

Actual charges depend on the service and billing model. Some plans bundle usage, while others charge according to consumption. Either way, repeated revisions also require your time.

A tool that appears inexpensive to generate can become costly to own if every change requires another lengthy troubleshooting session.

When a Ready-Made Joomla Extension Offers Better Value

Before building a substantial tool with AI, investigate whether an existing Joomla extension already meets your needs.

A reasonably priced extension may provide established functionality, documentation, updates, and access to support. Those benefits can be worth more than the initial savings from generating custom code.

For example, a booking system involves more than a calendar. It may need availability rules, cancellation handling, notifications, permissions, and reliable data storage. Recreating those connected functions introduces ongoing responsibilities.

Compare the full cost of ownership: purchase or subscription fees, setup time, AI usage, testing, maintenance, and professional help when needed.

Commercial extensions are not automatically secure or well maintained. Check compatibility, update history, documentation, and support availability. But when a reputable solution covers most of your requirements at a reasonable price, buying it is often the more practical choice.

AI-Generated Code Is Not Guaranteed to Be Secure

Code can work as expected and still contain security weaknesses.

An empirical study of AI-generated code found vulnerabilities in Python and JavaScript snippets used in public projects. Although the research was not specific to Joomla, it demonstrates why functioning output should not be treated as proof of security. Research on AI-generated code security

Privacy is another concern. The 2023 CodexLeaks study demonstrated that a code-generation model used in GitHub Copilot could reproduce sensitive personal information in generated completions under researchers’ test conditions. This documents a real leakage mechanism, rather than establishing how often current tools expose information in everyday use. USENIX CodexLeaks study

For website owners, the practical lesson is straightforward: inspect generated source code for passwords, API keys, personal information, and other sensitive details before installing or sharing it. Never place private credentials in browser-visible JavaScript.

Use placeholder data when asking AI for help. For anything involving customer records, payments, permissions, or sensitive database operations, arrange a qualified developer’s review. Asking AI to review its own output can help identify problems, but it is not an independent security guarantee.

Use AI to Customize or Repair Existing Extensions

AI can also help you understand and modify an extension you already use. This is especially valuable when its original developer is unreachable.

With a limited, clearly defined issue, AI may help explain an error, identify relevant code, suggest a compatibility fix, or adjust a feature to suit your workflow.

Start with a copy of the website in a separate testing environment. Describe the expected behavior, record the changes, and test related features as well as the immediate fix.

Where supported, prefer Joomla template overrides or documented extension mechanisms over direct edits. Changes made directly to an extension’s files may disappear during an update.

An AI-assisted repair can provide breathing room, but it does not restore ongoing developer support. If an abandoned extension handles sensitive data or essential business functions, evaluate a maintained replacement alongside any temporary fix.

Always Back Up Before Installing an Extension

Before installing any extension—whether purchased, downloaded for free, or generated with AI—back up your website.

The backup should include both files and the database. Keep a copy separate from the live website and confirm that you have a workable restoration process. Apply the same precaution before modifying or updating an existing extension.

Joomla’s own security checklist explicitly recommends backing up site files and the database before installing extensions. Joomla security checklist

Test changes on a staging copy whenever possible. A backup provides a recovery path; testing helps you avoid needing it.

Joomla’s Future: AI Assistance and Established Solutions

The strongest opportunity for Joomla is a practical combination of established software and selective AI assistance.

Use Joomla’s existing capabilities first. Choose maintained extensions when they solve complex requirements at a reasonable cost. Use AI for small tools, focused customizations, and carefully tested repairs.

AI lowers the barrier to creating code. The lasting value comes from choosing code you can safely operate, afford to maintain, and confidently update.

Say something here...
— Cancel
You are a guest ( Sign Up ? )
or post as a guest
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.

Be the first to comment.

✨ All extensions are now fully compatible with Joomla 5.4.x and 6.
Sign in to your account

Use your social accounts to sign in