Can JLex Review be used as a dedicated commenting tool?

11 years ago

I am looking for a tool that offers full commenting functionality, such as:
- threaded conversations
- Akismet support
- K2 comment count integration
- comment RSS
- comment functionality: subscribe, permalink, share, feature, report

If possible, please provide a sample URL(s)

Thank You

10 replies

Jacki

10 years ago

Actually the way these forums work seems to be what we are looking for... Do you have an extension that handles your forum feature?

Victor

11 years ago

Hello Joe,
Thanks for your interesting !

I please answer your questions:
- threaded conversations > Yes
- Akismet support > I don't try, but if it has plugin for Joomla, I think easy to integrate JLex Review.
- K2 comment count integration > Yes.
- comment RSS > No :-(
- comment functionality: subscribe, permalink, share, feature, report > Yes.

Joe Campbell

11 years ago

Please provide URL of demo or website utilizing threaded comment feature (comments not reviews) - Thank You

Victor

11 years ago

URL of demo: http://demo.jlexart.com/jlex-review/comment
p/s: You can change text (from review to comment) in language pack

Joe Campbell

11 years ago

1) The text reflects the experience - you should change to "comments"
2) Where is the "Reply" feature for threaded conversations?
3) Can Sort by & Find features be used for comments (please add)
4) Can you subscribe to the entire conversation or thread?
5) Can the Review description formatting be removed? (bold, media, current time, etc.)

Victor

11 years ago

1. Yep i will change, but I can only do it in next version

2. It line "Become a first comment..."
3,4,5 => You can set it in JLex Review config.

Joe Campbell

11 years ago

I just tested #2 - it only provides one level of threading and it must be in response to a review. This is not how commenting tools work. Comments should be about the content or other/previous comments.

As a review tool, this is great, but not ideal as a comment tool. I recommend you create a plugin or separate extension to better serve the needs of those who want a true commenting tool.

I hope you find my suggestions helpful.

Victor

11 years ago

Thanks for your opinion ! I will try to improve comment section in next version (or make a new extension)

Joe Campbell

11 years ago

Awesome - please email me directly if I can help in any way

Jacki

10 years ago

I am also wanting more of a Commenting function than a Review and am trying to alter the component to suit this purpose, but would love it if you made these options available!

Product Changelogs

JLex Block 6.2.5

# Upgrade the framework to be compatible with Joomla 6.1.x
# End of support for Joomla 3.

JLex Transfer 1.7.1

^ Filter articles by the selected time range.
^ Added a "resume migration" feature for cases of interruption.
^ Added advanced options for the category.
# Improve user interface
# Optimize the data importing.
# Fixed known issues

JLex Review 6.5.1

^ Bridging feature. See its documentation for details.
^ Option resize image if too large.
# Fixed route issue.
# Fixed known bugs.

JLex Comment 3.7.3

^ The option to accept the Terms & Conditions once
^ The option allows you to edit comments within X minutes.
^ Viewport - Optimize page loading speed.
^ "Roles" are now available to guests.
^ Added options to adjust image quality.
# Fixed the issue of not receiving notifications.
# Fixed the bugs reported on Pagespeed.

JLex GuestBook 2.1.2

# Fixed login with Facebook and retrieved a user's profile picture.
# Improve layout and assets.
# Fixed known bugs.

JLex Comment 3.6.7

^ Option to load script location (Head or Body Tag).
# Improve data structure.
# Fix known bugs.

JLex Review 6.4.7

# Fixed login with Facebook.
# Fixed the issue of being unable to retrieve a user's profile picture on Facebook.
# Fixed known bugs.

Can JLex Review be used as a dedicated commenting tool?

10 replies

Product Changelogs

60% Savings With Our Product Bundles

Resource

Joomla Extension

Connect with us

WRITE A REVIEW SPREAD THE WORD!